Share
  • Share this post on Delicious
  • StumbleUpon this post
  • Share this post on Digg
  • Tweet about this post
  • Share this post on Mixx
  • Share this post on Technorati
  • Share this post on Facebook
  • Share this post on NewsVine
  • Share this post on Reddit
  • Share this post on Google
  • Share this post on LinkedIn

Hey!!!! I know that guitar!!!!! I think…

I know this isn’t an Iceman. OK!!!!
Now here is a list that is an absolute crock of excrement. Blender.com recently published a list of the 28 Most Recognisable Guitars and I have to say it's pretty obvious they were running out of ideas towards the tale. The way the list has been done is very cool, but the contents is off the mark in several ways.

To me, the guitar is classed as recognisable if you see it and instantly associate it with a particular performer, and no other. Here is the list below, and I've bolded the ones I agree with:

You can read the complete article at Blender.com.

There is a real difference between recognising a guitar as the type a particular artist uses, and recognising the exact instrument that was played by the artists, or seeing a guitar and thinking of a musician who's identity is synonymous with the instrument. An example is that Lots of people play Les Pauls, but there is no confusing which one Zakk Wylde plays. Seeing a black fender Strat is not going to make me think of Eric Clapton instantly.

There are a few guitars that I think are missing from the list, like an Cracked Mirror Ibanez Iceman (Paul Stanley). Can anyone else think of a guitar missing from the list?

Related Posts with Thumbnails

About the author

Chris has written 567 articles for GuitarToyBox

Chris is a washed up has been grunge god trying to find redemption in the blues, but being side tracked by progressive metal, real life, and fantasies of composing professional wrestling theme music. He has a very out of date website at chriswatsonmusic.com and a home studio still in pieces one year on from moving house.He also tweets @chrislwatson.

19 Responses to "Hey!!!! I know that guitar!!!!! I think…"

  • Mad Stratter 11:57 AM 08/12/2007

    I'm surprised you take issue with the inclusion of Bo Diddley… how many other guys do you know who play a shoe-box-with-a-neck-guitar?

    It's apparent that they picked the number 28 ahead of time and struggled to meet that quota when they actually started thinking of guitars… they should have kept it to a list of 10 and left out all the fluff.

  • Mad Stratter 03:57 AM 09/12/2007

    I’m surprised you take issue with the inclusion of Bo Diddley… how many other guys do you know who play a shoe-box-with-a-neck-guitar?

    It’s apparent that they picked the number 28 ahead of time and struggled to meet that quota when they actually started thinking of guitars… they should have kept it to a list of 10 and left out all the fluff.

  • Wookie 05:55 PM 08/12/2007

    Whoops, that was one of the ones I meant to bold. I went over the list about 5 times making sure I didn;t miss any and I still did. Good spot.

  • Wookie 09:55 AM 09/12/2007

    Whoops, that was one of the ones I meant to bold. I went over the list about 5 times making sure I didn;t miss any and I still did. Good spot.

  • Jol Dantzig 10:14 AM 09/12/2007

    There's so many ways to interpret this list, depending upon your viewpoint.
    Imagine if you walked into a room where all of the guitars on the list were hanging up on the walls, and you had to name each guitar's owner…

    That's one way to look at it.

    Another would be if the names of guitarists were listed, and you had to name their main guitar…

    Hey, where's John Lennon's black Rickenbacker? Or Merle's Bigsby? Or Charlie Christian's ES 150?

    In the end, it's not really worth arguing about.

  • Jol Dantzig 02:14 AM 10/12/2007

    There’s so many ways to interpret this list, depending upon your viewpoint.
    Imagine if you walked into a room where all of the guitars on the list were hanging up on the walls, and you had to name each guitar’s owner…

    That’s one way to look at it.

    Another would be if the names of guitarists were listed, and you had to name their main guitar…

    Hey, where’s John Lennon’s black Rickenbacker? Or Merle’s Bigsby? Or Charlie Christian’s ES 150?

    In the end, it’s not really worth arguing about.

  • Wookie 03:52 PM 09/12/2007

    “Imagine if you walked into a room where all of the guitars on the list were hanging up on the walls, and you had to name each guitarÂ’s ownerÂ…”

    Thats exactly where I am coming from. But you are right. It's not really that important, but makes a damn good discussion topic, that's for sure.

  • Wookie 07:52 AM 10/12/2007

    “Imagine if you walked into a room where all of the guitars on the list were hanging up on the walls, and you had to name each guitar’s owner…”

    Thats exactly where I am coming from. But you are right. It’s not really that important, but makes a damn good discussion topic, that’s for sure.

  • Matt Willian 07:53 PM 09/12/2007

    uhh Jack White's airline is pretty recognizeable…
    also suprising that they didn't include Steve Vai's Jem

  • Wookie 08:40 PM 09/12/2007

    It is, but when I see it I don't instantly think Jack White, whereas I'm sure a lot of people do. The Jem however is a good call. I would think it doesn't make their list because outside the guitar world Vai isn't exactly a household name.

  • Matt Willian 11:53 AM 10/12/2007

    uhh Jack White’s airline is pretty recognizeable…
    also suprising that they didn’t include Steve Vai’s Jem

  • Wookie 12:40 PM 10/12/2007

    It is, but when I see it I don’t instantly think Jack White, whereas I’m sure a lot of people do. The Jem however is a good call. I would think it doesn’t make their list because outside the guitar world Vai isn’t exactly a household name.

  • Dave 08:12 PM 20/12/2007

    Joe Strummer's Tele. Sunburst spraypainted black (poorly) with the black (and in some places, the sunburst) worn through, with a sticker that says “Ignore Alien Orders”. Wonderful.

    James Burton's Tele: Pink Paisley. Fender thought they'd sell 'em to hippies, but the only folks I've ever heard of playing 'em are country guys.

    Waylon Jennings' Tele: Covered with Black leather with white figures sewn on. As much a part of the opening to Dukes of Hazzard as the orange Dodge Charger.

    Clarence White's Tele, then Marty Stuart's Tele: A late-50s sunburst Tele, with a Strat pick in the neck, a German griffin sticker behind the bridge and a whole freakin' other body bolted on to hold the B-Bender hardware. Leave it to a hot country picker to play a double-wide.

    Springsteen's Esquire: Retrofitted with a neck pickup. Black pickguard, blonde body. The black-and-white pick on the cover to Born To Run made it iconographic.

    Jerry Garcia's later customs (to prove I'm not only a Tele fan): Beautiful rich rosewood with gold appointments. I can't look at things like some Ibanez S series guitars without thinking about a Steal Your Face sticker behind the bridge, even if their actual shape looks more like a BC Rich take on a Stratocaster.

    Lonnie Mack's Flying V: He had a V. He wanted a tremelo bridge. He found a Bigsby, but it was a tailpiece Bigsby. So he connected the wings of the V with a metal rod to hook the tailpiece to. Nobody's rockin' a Flying V like this one!

  • Dave 08:23 PM 20/12/2007

    And I forgot. George Lynch's Mr. Scary: You could give George Lynch a bog-standard Strat or Les Paul and film only his right hand, without sound, and I would say, “Hey, that's George Lynch!” And he has had a few notable paintjobs on his superstrats. The Kamikaze. The tiger stripe. But Mr. Scary is the skull and bones. Scary halloween art with a neck. It's him.

  • Dave 12:12 PM 21/12/2007

    Joe Strummer’s Tele. Sunburst spraypainted black (poorly) with the black (and in some places, the sunburst) worn through, with a sticker that says “Ignore Alien Orders”. Wonderful.

    James Burton’s Tele: Pink Paisley. Fender thought they’d sell ‘em to hippies, but the only folks I’ve ever heard of playing ‘em are country guys.

    Waylon Jennings’ Tele: Covered with Black leather with white figures sewn on. As much a part of the opening to Dukes of Hazzard as the orange Dodge Charger.

    Clarence White’s Tele, then Marty Stuart’s Tele: A late-50s sunburst Tele, with a Strat pick in the neck, a German griffin sticker behind the bridge and a whole freakin’ other body bolted on to hold the B-Bender hardware. Leave it to a hot country picker to play a double-wide.

    Springsteen’s Esquire: Retrofitted with a neck pickup. Black pickguard, blonde body. The black-and-white pick on the cover to Born To Run made it iconographic.

    Jerry Garcia’s later customs (to prove I’m not only a Tele fan): Beautiful rich rosewood with gold appointments. I can’t look at things like some Ibanez S series guitars without thinking about a Steal Your Face sticker behind the bridge, even if their actual shape looks more like a BC Rich take on a Stratocaster.

    Lonnie Mack’s Flying V: He had a V. He wanted a tremelo bridge. He found a Bigsby, but it was a tailpiece Bigsby. So he connected the wings of the V with a metal rod to hook the tailpiece to. Nobody’s rockin’ a Flying V like this one!

  • Dave 12:23 PM 21/12/2007

    And I forgot. George Lynch’s Mr. Scary: You could give George Lynch a bog-standard Strat or Les Paul and film only his right hand, without sound, and I would say, “Hey, that’s George Lynch!” And he has had a few notable paintjobs on his superstrats. The Kamikaze. The tiger stripe. But Mr. Scary is the skull and bones. Scary halloween art with a neck. It’s him.

  • Wookie 02:39 AM 22/12/2007

    Now those are some great suggestions. Another one I thought of was Rory Gallagher's strat where he had rubbed the entire finish away.

  • Wookie 06:39 PM 22/12/2007

    Now those are some great suggestions. Another one I thought of was Rory Gallagher’s strat where he had rubbed the entire finish away.

  • jmevans12 06:46 PM 23/11/2008

    Yeah, Garcia's guitar has been viewed by more people in person then any other. I think if you took a pole from everyone in America and said who's guitar is this? several million deadheads would know “rosebud” (probably by name). What other guitar if you posted it would SEVERAL MILLION people know? Maybe eddie van halen's “frankenstein” Jimi's strat would just look like a strat to people who didn't know guitars, same with most of the others; unrecognizable from guitars of the same make,model and color. But if you don't know deadhead culture, it's kind of a shocker.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

GTB On Flickr

Flickr is currently unavailable.

Social Networks

Follow me in these Social Networks

Facebook
YouTube
Flickr
Stumbleupon
Technorati
Twitter

Chris's Twitter Feed